Data+Provenance+Use+Case+Harmonization+and+Standards

include component="page" wikiName="siframework" page="DP header" =Standards & Harmonization Announcements=

The Data Provenance Harmonization Phase kicked off on October 23, 2014.

 * All Hands meetings are moving to a bi-weekly schedule - the next meeting will be Thursday, November 12th, 2015. **

Please join us for our next Data Provenance All Hands Call on **November 12th from 2:00-3:00pm Eastern Standard Time**.

The Final Functional Requirements Document developed in response to the HITSC Data ProvenanceTask Force Recommendations was reviewed on the 5/28 All Hands Call and is available

The Data Provenance initiative is currently seeking pilots. If you are interested in participating, please email Jamie.parker@esacinc.com or fill out the interest form on the Wiki.

Harmonization Timeline


=Harmonization Work-In-Progress Documents= The table below includes the Harmonization content that was covered in the most recent meetings. Each week the Harmonization documents will be updated based on the content reviewed during the All Hands meeting.

-Shared updates on the status of the LPHI Pilots -Did a deep dive into the HL7 DPROV Implementation Guide || -Shared updates on the status of the LPHI Pilots -Reviewed the Data Provenance Standards Analysis Crosswalk || - Shared updates on the RAIN and LPHI pilot preparation || -Reviewed the Data Provenance Standards Analysis Crosswalk with the SMEs || -Presentation by Mohammed Islam and Robert Moerland from Louisiana Public Health Institute on their organization's goals and plan for piloting -Presentation by Timothy Tyndall and Ayami Tyndall from RAIN Network on their organization's goals and plan for piloting || -Introduced the Standards Analysis Crosswalk, which maps the candidate standards to the requirements from the Use Case and Functional Requirements document || -Introduced the UCR crosswalk || -Presentation by Gajen Sunthara, ONC Presidential Innovation Fellow || -Jeff Tackes presented on USPS's provenance-related capabilities || -Shared the pilot recruitment status and the plan for upcoming community meetings || -Gary Dickinson walked through the changes and additions to the HL7 FHIR EHR Record Lifecycle Event Implementation Guide and the FHIR W5 Report || -Shared announcements regarding the pilot phase of the initiative || -Introduced Rose-Marie Nsahlai as the new ONC/OCPO Sponsor -Reviewed the new S&I process for developing technical solutions and implementation guidance with input from pilot organizations || -Reviewed the Functional Requirements document, which summarizes the discussions that the Information Interchange and System Requirements SWGs had over the past few months || -Further defined what it means to "change" data -Discussed the SWG's recommendation for the involved of digital signatures in data provenance || For the System Requirements SWG: -Reviewed the candidate standards list that we developed on the last All Hands Call -Defined what it means to "change" data -Discussed the security implications as they relate to the system requirements The Information Interchange Discussions finished up on the 4/30 All Hands Call || -Considered the implications of privacy and security aspects as they relate to information interchange and discussed the policy considerations related to system behaviors -Reviewed the 'Action Reason,' 'Data Reason,' 'Author Signature,' and 'System, Device or Software Signature' data elements; Identified a short list of candidate standards that meet our core requirements; chose a definition for what it means to 'change' data || - Revisited possible payload standards (assuming content neutral transport) that align with MU2 and MU3 - Information Interchange SWG -Continued the discussion on transport standards that support the core information interchange requirements and the payload - Information Interchange SWG -Reviewed the Data Provenance System Event Matrix. More specifically, we highlighted data elements that need to be defined and further discussed, and we edited the matrix to reflect that data can be pulled from the receiving system, in addition to being pushed from the source EHR system || -Discussed possible payload standards (assuming content neutral transport) that align with MU2 and MU3 - Information Interchange SWG -Discussed transport standards that support the core information interchange requirements and the payload - Information Interchange SWG -Reviewed the Data Provenance System Event Matrix, and more specifically, we disambiguated the role of the "Author" - System Requirements SWG || -Answered the question, "what do we need to know?" and began developing a list of corresponding Data Elements - Information Interchange SWG -Reviewed the Data Provenance System Event Matrix, and more specifically, the "Provenance Events" and "Exchanges (w/ and w/o transformation)" sections - System Requirements SWG || -Further defined the framing assumptions for Information Interchange -Reviewed the Data Provenance System Event Matrix || -Discussed the framing assumptions for Information Interchange -Discussed the system requirements need to establish a 'chain of trust' -Reviewed the Data Provenance System Event Matrix || -Reviewed the plan and timeline for the Information Interchange SWG -Elaborated on the Information Interchange framing questions and what it means to 'change' data -Reviewed the Minimum Provenance Requirements spreadsheet || -Heard a report out from the 2/27 System Requirements SWG Call. -Discussed the plan, goals, and timeline for the Information Interchange SWG. || - Reviewed the plan, goals, and timeline for the System Requirements SWG - Reviewed and discussed the initial list of Data Elements taken from the DPROV Use Case || - Heard updates on the status of HITSC Task Force Recommendations -Heard an overview of the tentative plan, goals, and timeline for the System Functional and Information Interchange Requirements SWGs || -Reviewed the process for receiving formal recommendations from the Data Provenance Task Force and HITSC -Heard a presentation on the CDISC Operational Data Model from Sam Hume || -Heard a summary of the HL7 Meeting activities -Reviewed the Data Provenance Task Force's recommendations to HITSC -Reviewed the Harmonization process and the tentative plan moving forward ||
 * **Document** || **Date Uploaded** || **Summary** ||
 * [[file:dprov_community_allhands-2015-09-17.pptx|9.17 All Hands Materials]] || 9/17/2015 || 9/17 All Hands:
 * [[file:dprov_community_allhands-2015-09-03.pptx|9.3 All Hands Materials]] || 9/8/2015 || 9/3 All Hands:
 * [[file:dprov_community_allhands-2015-08-20.pptx| 8.20 All Hands Materials]] || 8/21/2015 || 8/20 All Hands:
 * [[file:dprov_community_allhands-2015-08-13.pptx|8.13 All Hands Materials]] || 8/14/2015 || 8/13 All Hands:
 * [[file:dprov_community_allhands-2015-08-06.pptx|8.6 All Hands Materials]] || 8/6/2015 || 8/6 All Hands:
 * [[file:dprov_community_allhands-2015-07-30.pptx|7.30 All Hands Materials ]] || 7/30/2015 || 7/30 All Hands:
 * [[file:dprov_community_allhands-2015-07-23.pptx|7.23 All Hands Materials ]] || 7/24/2015 || 7/23 All Hands:
 * [[file:dprov_community_allhands-2015-07-16.pptx|7.16 All Hands Materials]] || 7/24/2015 || 7/16 All Hands:
 * [[file:dprov_community_allhands-2015-07-09.pptx| 7.9 All Hands Materials]] || 7/10/2015 || 7/9 All Hands:
 * [[file:dprov_community_allhands-2015-07-02.pptx| 7.2 All Hands Materials]] || 7/6/2015 || 7/2 All Hands:
 * [[file:dprov_community_allhands-2015-06-25.pptx|6.25 All Hands Materials]] || 6/26/2015 || 6/25 All Hands:
 * [[file:dprov_community_allhands-2015-06-18.pptx| 6.18 All Hands Materials]] || 6/19/2015 || 6/18 All Hands:
 * [[file:dprov_community_allhands-2015-06-11.pptx| 6.11 All Hands Materials]] || 6/11/2015 || 6/11 All Hands:
 * [[file:dprov_community_allhands-2015-05-28.pptx| 5.28 All Hands Materials]] || 5/29/2015 || 5/28 All Hands:
 * [[file:dprov_community_allhands-2015-05-21.pptx| 5.21 All Hands Materials]] || 5/22/2015 || 5/21 All Hands:
 * [[file:dprov_community_allhands-2015-05-7.pptx| 5.7 All Hands Materials ]] || 5/8/2015 || 5/7 All Hands:
 * [[file:dprov_community_allhands-2015-04-30.pptx|4.30 All Hands Materials]] || 5/1/2015 || 4/30 All Hands:
 * [[file:dprov_community_allhands-2015-04-23-post meeting edits.pptx|4.23 All Hands Materials]] || 4/24/2015 || 4/23 All Hands:
 * [[file:Candidate Standards Final_with SMEs_4_20_15.xlsx|Community Review: Candidate Standards List (Updated)]] || 4/20/2015 ||  ||
 * [[file:dprov_community_allhands-2015-04-09.pptx|4.9 All Hands Materials]] || 4/9/2015 || 4/9 All Hands:
 * [[file:dprov_community_allhands-2015-04-02-1.pptx|4.2 All Hands Materials]] || 4/2/2015 || 4/2 All Hands:
 * [[file:dprov_community_allhands-2015-03-26.pptx|3.26 All Hands Materials]] || 3/27/2015 || 3/26 All Hands:
 * [[file:dprov_community_allhands-2015-03-19 as delivered.pptx|3.19 All Hands Materials]] || 3/27/2015 || 3/19 All Hands:
 * [[file:dprov_community_allhands-2015-03-12.pptx|3.12 All Hands Materials]] || 3/27/2015 || 3/12 All Hands:
 * [[file:dprov_community_allhands-2015-03-05 as delivered.pptx|3.5 All Hands Materials]] || 3/9/2015 || 3/5 All Hands:
 * [[file:dprov_community_allhands-2015-02-26_v2.pptx|2.26 All Hands Materials]] || 2/26/2015 || 2/16 All hands:
 * [[file:dprov_community_allhands-2015-02-19v2.pptx|2.19 All Hands Materials]] || 2/20/2015 || 2/19 All Hands:
 * [[file:dprov_community_allhands-2015-02-05.pptx|2.5 All Hands Materials]] || 2/5/2015 || 2/5 All Hands:
 * [[file:dprov_community_allhands-2015-01-29v2.pptx|1.29 All Hands Materials]] || 2/1/2015 || 1/29 All Hands:
 * [[file:dprov_community_allhands-2015-01-15_V2.pptx|1.15 All Hands Materials]]



|| 1/15/2015 || 1/15 All Hands: -Gary Dickinson provides an overview of the HL7 FHIR DSTU Release 1.1 Provenance Resource -Brief discusion on how the FHIR Provenance Resource compares to the W3C Spec -Kathleen Connor finishes her presentation on the grouping of HL7 Implementation Guides and the associated vocabulary from the 1/8/2015 All Hands Call || - Kathleen Connor provides and over view of the following grouping of Implementation Guides and the associated vocabulary: 1. HL7 Health Care Privacy and Security Classification System, Release 1 2. HL7 V3: Privacy, Access and Security Services (PASS) 3. HL7 V3: Privacy, Access and Security Services; Security Labelling Service, Release 1 (SLS) 4. Data Segmentation for Privacy (DS4P) - Kathleen Connor + Serafina Versaggi provide and overview of HL7 Implementation Guide for CDA, Release 2: Consent Directives, Release 1 || - Bob Dieterle provides an overview of HL7 Implementation Guide for CDA R2: Digital Signatures and Delegation of Rights, Release 1 - Diana Warner and Reed Gelzer provide an overview of HL7 EHR Records Management and Evidentiary Support (RM-ES) Functional Model, Release 1 ||
 * [[file:dprov_community_allhands-2015-01-08v2.pptx|1.8 All Hands Materials]] || 1/9/2015 || 1/8 All Hands:
 * [[file:dprov_community_allhands-2014-12-18.pptx|12.18 All Hands Materials]] || 12/29/2014 || 12/18 All Hands:
 * [[file:dprov_community_allhands-2014-12-11.pptx| 12.11 All Hands Materials]]



|| 12/11/2014 || 12/11 All Hands: -Gary Dickinson provides overviews of: 1. HL7 EHR Interoperability Model DSTU (2007) 2. HL7 Implementation Guide for CDA Release 2: Reference Profile for EHR Interoperability Model DSTU (2008) 3. HL7 EHR Lifecycle Model DSTU (2008) 4. ISO/HL7 10781 EHR System Functional Model, Release 2 (2014) 5. HL7 Record Lifecycle Events on FHIR (project underway 2014 for FHIR DSTU Release 2) || -Review Candidate Standards Presentation Schedule -Bob Yencha and Kathleen Connor provide overviews and related provenance guidance within: 1. CDA R2 2. HL7 Implementation Guide for CDA R2: Data Provenance, R1 3. HL7 V2 ||
 * [[file:dprov_community_allhands-2014-12-04.pptx|12.4 All Hands Materials]] || 12/5/2014 || 12/4 All Hands:
 * [[file:Candidate Standards Final_with SMEs_11_18.xlsx|Community Review: Candidate Standards List (Updated)]]



|| 11/21/2014 || Artifacts for Review: -Candidate Standards List

11/20 All Hands: -Review Candidate Standards presentation schedule -Address community comments on the Candidate Standards list -Glen Marshall provides overview of SOAP -Gary Dickinson provides overview of ISO 21089 Health Information: Trusted End-to-End Flows (2004) ||
 * [[file:Candidate Standards Final_with SMEs_11-13.xlsx|Community Review: Candidate Standards List (Updated)]]



|| 11/13/2014 || Artifacts for Review: -Candidate Standards List

11/13 All Hands: -Provide recap of end-to-end workflow analysis -Review all candidate standards, identify points of contact to serve as standard experts -Satya Sahoo provides overview of W3C Prov Specifications || -Use Case End-to-End Workflow Diagram
 * [[file:dprov_community_allhands-2014-11-06 (2).pptx|11.6 All Hands Materials]] || 11/13/2014 || Artifacts for Review:

11/6 All Hands: -Discuss system and information interchange requirements as part of end-to-end Use Case diagram -Identify and confirm provenance metadata events ||
 * [[file:Data Provenance Candidate Standards List_10_24.xlsx|Community Review: Candidate Standards List]]

|| 10/24/2014 || Artifacts for Review: -Candidate Standards List

10/23 All Hands: -Provide overview of S&I Harmonization Process -Introduce and review Candidate Standards || 

media type="custom" key="26735060" media type="custom" key="26735006"

=Finalized Harmonization Artifacts=
 * **Artifact** || **Date Finalized** || **File** ||

include component="page" wikiName="siframework" page="DP Contacts"