Certificate+Discovery+for+Direct+Project+2011-08-22


 * Meeting Date**: 08/22/ 2011
 * Meeting Title:** PD Certificate Discovery for Direct Project SWG Meeting Session 11

Agenda/Objectives:
http://wiki.siframework.org/Volunteer+Recommendation+Review
 * **Topic** || **Presenter** ||= **Time Allotted** ||
 * Wrap up Strengths and weaknesses in both the DNS and LDAP - Blue Edits || Ken Pool || 10 min ||
 * Review Implementation guidelines for publishing and discovering LDAP services using the DNS SRV Record || Support Team || 40 min ||
 * Work to be performed || Support Team ||= 20 min ||
 * LDAP X.500 References || Ken/Peter || 10 min ||
 * Q&A || Support Team || 10 min ||

Attendees:
__Workgroup Attendees:__ To be updated

__Panelist Attendees:__ Erik Pupo, Jonathan Tadese, Kelly Conlin

**Action Items:**
“Yes with comments” were provided by Brett Peterson and McLain Causey ||
 * **Date** || **Description** || **Owner** || **Status** || **Notes** ||
 * 8/15/2011 || Implementation guidelines for publishing and discovering LDAP services using the DNS SRV record || John Moehrke || OPEN || Refer to Volunteer Recommendation Review Wiki Page ||
 * 8/1/2011 || Develop Recommendation Statement for DNS/ LDAP Hybrid Approach || Bob Dieterle || CLOSED || Refer to Volunteer Recommendation Review Wiki Page ||
 * 7/25/11 || Develop LDAP guidance || Erik, Bob, John, Peter, Les, Ken, Alex, and any other interested SWG members || CLOSED ||  ||
 * 7/18/11 || Gain clarity from ONC regarding universal certificate discoverability || Harmonization Support Team || OPEN || Refer to meeting minutes below ||
 * 7/18/11 || Conduct preliminary environmental scans || All SWG Members || OPEN || Refer to Query for Digital Certificate for Direct Project - Ecosystem Consensus Wiki Page ||
 * 7/18/11 || Gain clarity regarding when Direct Rules of the Road will be finalized || Harmonization Support Team || OPEN || Refer to Direct Project Recommendation Review ||
 * 7/18/11 || Present revisions made to the Use Case to address “No” and “Yes with comments” votes from Committed Members || Use Case Support Leads || CLOSED || “No” votes were provided by Les Keepper and Ernest Grove.

__**Meeting Minutes:**__
Clarification regarding the terminology 'consensus' on the Volunteer Recommendation Page
 * Consensus changed to 'informal consensus'

The ability to look up an SRV record exists, it's only a matter of what format the SRV is in.

Most of the political commentary re: LDAP can be removed. LDAP is intended to be used for the Electronic Service Information Discovery, not the Certificate Discovery.

Discussion regarding whether or not Peter and Ken should either revise the LDAP/ X.500 Review Page in terms of being relevant to this use case and relevant as part of the solution instead of the solution in the entirety or migrate the entire section elsewhere.
 * Karen would prefer to leave this section attached to this Use Case so it won't be lost in the future and can be referenced.
 * Need to include direct statements regarding adoption.
 * First five paragraphs to be removed from this use case, bullet points will stay.
 * Discussion to continue on the next work group call.